CompAndSave is proud to offer affordable prices on our replacement HP LaserJet Pro M404dn toner cartridges that boast genuine-like quality and satisfaction. Why choose CompAndSave in shopping for HP M404dn toner cartridges?

  • LOWER PRICE, SAME QUALITY. Our HP cartridges are designed to ensure you get the same quality as OEM cartridges at a much lower price. Purchasing HP M404dn toner cartridges from CompAndSave means you get to save up to $1,300.40 (59% off retail price), but still having the same powder formula and number of high-quality prints. If you want to know your savings per print, check out our guide on how to calculate printing cost per page.
  • MADE WITH PRECISION. Worried about the installation of your new replacement HP LaserJet M404dn toner cartridges? Don't be. CompAndSave's cartridges are designed to work and perform like the original ones.
  • BUMP UP YOUR SAVINGS. Enjoy bigger discounts if you order HP LaserJet Pro M404dn toner cartridges in bulk. We have single and combo pack cartridges available, like our single pack for black HP 58A toner cartridge (CF258A) or combo pack of 4 HP LaserJet 58A black toner cartridges (CF258A). Mix and match different quantities to find the price break that's within your budget.
  • NEXT DAY SHIPPING. HP M404dn toner cartridge orders placed before 2:00 p.m. PST Monday through Friday will be processed the same day. Orders placed after 2:00 p.m. PST will be processed the following business day. Check our Shipping Policy for more information.
  • FREE SHIPPING. For U.S. orders, checking out $50 or more means the shipping fee is on us!
  • ECO-FRIENDLY SOLUTIONS. Did you know that our replacement or remanufactured cartridges are environmentally friendly? Instead of throwing away empty original HP cartridges, our manufacturer meticulously recycles them to function exactly like the originals. By purchasing our replacement HP LaserJet Pro M404dn toner cartridges, you will not only save a ton of money, but you will also be helping to preserve the environment.
  • SATISFACTION GUARANTEE. CompAndSave is so confident in the quality of our replacement HP LaserJet Pro M404dn cartridges that we offer a FULL refund for orders returned within ten days upon delivery. We even issue refunds or store credits up to 365 days from purchase! Make sure to read our Return Policy for more details.
  • WILL NOT VOID PRINTER WARRANTY. Using a replacement HP LaserJet Pro M404dn toner cartridge will never void your printer warranty. Visit our Ink Knowledge Base page for more details, or contact us for other concerns.

Take advantage of our exclusive prices for HP M404dn toner cartridges now. Get more SAVINGS without sacrificing quality today!

HP LaserJet Pro M404dn Toner Cartridges

Free shipping on orders $50 or more
All ink & toner come with a one-year 100% satisfaction guarantee.
Our products will never void your printer's warranty.

Replacement HP LaserJet Pro M404dn Toner Cartridges from $39.99

View:
Retail Price: $211.98
$129.98
Eligible for free shipping

Save $82.00 (39% off retail price)

   
High yield cartridge. Contains more ink and print more pages.
High Yield HP58X Toner Cartridges 2-Pack - Black
Replacement HP58X Toner Cartridges 2 Pack - CF258X Black - High Yield
Retail Price: $443.98
$147.98
Eligible for free shipping

Save $296.00 (67% off retail price)

   
Retail Price: $423.96
$251.96
Eligible for free shipping

Save $172.00 (41% off retail price)

   
High yield cartridge. Contains more ink and print more pages.
High Yield HP LaserJet 58X Toner Cartridges 4-Pack
Replacement HP LaserJet 58X Toner Cartridges 4-Pack - CF258X Black - High Yield
Retail Price: $887.96
$283.96
Eligible for free shipping

Save $604.00 (68% off retail price)

   
Retail Price: $1,059.90
$609.90
Eligible for free shipping

Save $450.00 (42% off retail price)

   
High yield cartridge. Contains more ink and print more pages.
High Yield HP 58X Black LaserJet Toner Cartridges 10-Pack
Retail Price: $2,219.90
$689.90
Eligible for free shipping

Save $1,530.00 (69% off retail price)

   
HP 58A Toner Cartridge Black, Single Pack
Replacement HP 58A Toner Cartridge - CF258A - Black
Retail Price: $116.99
$68.99
Eligible for free shipping

Save $48.00 (41% off retail price)

   
High yield cartridge. Contains more ink and print more pages.
High Yield HP CF258X Toner Cartridge Black, Single Pack
Replacement HP CF258X Toner Cartridge - 58X Black - High Yield
Retail Price: $244.99
$77.99
Eligible for free shipping

Save $167.00 (68% off retail price)

   
Retail Price: $105.99
$39.99

Save $66.00 (62% off retail price)

   
High yield cartridge. Contains more ink and print more pages.
HP 58X High Yield Toner Cartridge Black, Single Pack
Replacement HP 58X High Yield Toner Cartridge - CF258X Black - No Chip
Retail Price: $221.99
$47.89

Save $174.10 (78% off retail price)

   
$319.99
Eligible for free shipping

 

   

HP LaserJet Pro M404dn Toner Replacement Guide

  1. To access the HP LaserJet Pro M404dn toner cartridge, just simply open the front door of the printer by pressing the release button on the left side of the printer.
  2. Carefully pull the empty toner from the printer from the slot.
  3. Get your new CompAndSave HP M404dn toner cartridge. Open the cartridge over a sink or garbage can to avoid any mess in case of a powder leak, as sometimes, factories tend to overfill the toner cartridges. Gently shake the toner cartridge five to six times and avoid touching the bottom part of the toner, then remove the covering tape that is usually bright in color as well as the plastic protective case, if there is, before installing it.
  4. Carefully align and insert the HP 404dn toner cartridge into its slot until it is firmly seated in place.
  5. Close the toner cartridge access door.

HP LaserJet Pro M404dn Toner Cartridges FAQ's

Can you refill HP LaserJet toner cartridges?

Yes, genuine toner cartridges are refillable; however, it is not recommended since you have to replace some parts of the toner as well. If you think of refilling an empty toner cartridge, please bear in mind the following pros and cons. The major advantage of refilling is cost-efficiency. It'll be a way cheaper option rather than purchasing a new genuine one. On the other hand, refilled toner cartridges can have issues with the print quality and durability. Toner consists of different parts such as rolling gears, cleaning blades, etc. These parts wear out over time which can cause noise when printing, low-quality printouts, and even leakage inside the printer. Another thing to look into is the imaging drum; these hold the image before the toner powder is applied to the paper. Just like the toner, parts of the imaging drum also wear and tear over time.

To sum it all up, we highly encourage you to have it refilled through stores that offer refilling services instead. If you choose to purchase a new one, we at CompAndSave offer a wide variety of cheap printer toner cartridges at a much lesser price without compromising its quality. Our toners are manufactured to meet or exceed the OEM specifications, which will save you from all the trouble of going through the process of refilling a toner cartridge.

What toner does M404dn use?
HP LaserJet Pro M404dn printer uses the standard yield HP 58A and the high yield HP 58X toner cartridges. CompAndSave offers replacement HP 58A and HP 58X toner cartridges that can match and provide the same quality as the OEM but without the hefty price tag.
Why is HP LaserJet toner so expensive?
OEM ink and toner manufacturers claim that the high cost of toner cartridges is due to the research and development of technologies to deliver high-quality ink and toner. However, it is worth noting that there are generic cartridges that exceed OEM requirements while being less expensive than their counterparts. CompAndSave's compatible and replacement ink and toner cartridges are engineered to meet or exceed OEM standards. That is to say; you can have the same print quality and page output without spending a fortune. Please keep in mind that using generic, remanufactured, or replacement cartridges will never void the warranty on your printer. For additional information, please visit ink knowledge base, and you will be redirected to the right page.

Replacement HP LaserJet Pro M404dn Toner Cartridges Reviews

46 Customer Reviews
4.6 out of 5 stars
Sort by
Rating
Newest
Helpfulness
  • The seller does not answer support tickets.
    Review for Replacement HP CF258X Toner Cartridge - 58X Black - High Yield
    Dec 27, 2023
    By:
    The printer will give a message that a used cartridge has been installed. The ink supply status will no longer function. I printed a test page. With the original cartridge a set of screened blocks were very smoothly rendered. With the replacement cartridge the blocks were slightly darker, and showed some irregularity/banding. A cross hatched line surrounded by a box composed of alternating screened and solid lines was clearly discernible with the original cartridge. With the replacement cartridge the screened portion of the box was almost entirely filled in. There were also couple blotchy areas in the solid lines. I showed the test pages to my wife; her comment was "Good enough". I'm not sure I can fully recommend this thing, but it sure is cheaper than a genuine cartridge. The seller does not answer support tickets.
    Was this review helpful?
  • Review for Replacement HP CF258X Toner Cartridge - 58X Black - High Yield
    Dec 7, 2023
    By: Verified Buyer
    Inserted cartridge, began printing! Easy, least.
    Was this review helpful?
  • Great product
    Review for Replacement HP CF258X Toner Cartridge - 58X Black - High Yield
    Oct 26, 2023
    By: Verified Buyer
    Easy to load. Works great
    Was this review helpful?
  • Outstanding product.
    Review for Replacement HP 58A Toner Cartridge - CF258A - Black
    Sep 28, 2023
    By:
    Outstanding product. Work great!
    Was this review helpful?
  • How about recycling old cartridges?
    Review for Replacement HP 58X High Yield Toner Cartridge - CF258X Black - No Chip
    Nov 17, 2022
    By: Verified Buyer
    Came in two days Perfect. Used them numerous tines
    Was this review helpful?
  • Top quality. A+
    Review for Replacement HP CF258X Toner Cartridge - 58X Black - High Yield
    Oct 8, 2022
    By:
    Works just as well as the previous $250 cartridge. Comes with micro chip and ready to be installed!
    Was this review helpful?
  • correct product and works great
    Review for Replacement HP 58X High Yield Toner Cartridge - CF258X Black - No Chip
    Jul 12, 2022
    By:
    correct product and works great
    Was this review helpful?
  • Review for Replacement HP58X Toner Cartridges 2 Pack - CF258X Black - High Yield
    Jun 28, 2022
    By: Verified Buyer
    Great product. Delivers on your promises. Good price. Quite a savings! Thank you! A great blessing to get a substantial savings (over the "official" toner from the dealer, especially in Biden's and the Squad's economy.
    Was this review helpful?
  • Review for Replacement HP CF258X Toner Cartridge - 58X Black - High Yield
    Jun 15, 2022
    By: Verified Buyer
    Great product. Does just what is advertised. Good price.
    Was this review helpful?
  • Was hesitant as the toner ...
    Review for Replacement HP 58A Toner Cartridge - CF258A - Black
    Jun 10, 2022
    By:
    Was hesitant as the toner had a chip. But it worked just like they said it would
    Was this review helpful?